Commercial partnership. This article contains affiliate links. If you book through these links, Pixidia earns a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Top of the Rock for a first visit and the best photo, the Empire State Building for the icon and the night view. The Empire State’s 86th-floor deck sits at about 320 m (1,050 ft) and Top of the Rock’s at about 259 m (850 ft), but the latter keeps the Empire State in your frame. On tickets, expect €45.29 versus €41.35 per adult, with ratings of 4.46 and 4.28. My plan: Top of the Rock by day, the Empire State in the evening.
You have one slot to go up, and two names in mind: the Empire State Building or Top of the Rock? I compared both, then looked for what really changes the visit, using Viator prices checked over the 6 October to 4 November 2026 window. The answer depends less on height than on what you want in your photo.
My verdict comes down to one sentence per profile. For a first visit, I pick Top of the Rock, because the Empire State Building is in the frame and the Central Park view is the best in Midtown. For the icon, the south of Manhattan and the night, I pick the Empire State. The comparisons I read don’t agree: some put the Empire State first, others Top of the Rock, and I’d rather tell you that than invent a consensus.
One caveat, because I owe you transparency: the two standard tickets, the Empire State one (4.46) and the Top of the Rock one (4.28), have respectable ratings but fall below my usual 4.7 threshold. I keep them because they are literally the two products behind the question. Around them, I added eight higher-rated options: a premium SUMMIT One Vanderbilt visit, a tour that includes One World Observatory, a Hudson Yards stop, a helicopter flight, two cruises and a guided day.
Why compare two observation decks in New York: the Pixidia angle
The Empire State Building welcomes about 4 million visitors a year, Top of the Rock about 2.5 million [Our Escape Clause, Where Are Those Morgans]. Both are in Midtown, a few subway stops apart, and that is exactly why the choice is hard: you are not looking for a place, you are looking for an angle on Manhattan.
What each view gives you
From the Empire State, you see Rockefeller Center, the Chrysler Building, One World Trade Center, Central Park, Times Square, and on a clear day the Statue of Liberty and the Brooklyn Bridge [The Better Vacation]. The southern angle is better than at Top of the Rock. The obvious limit: you can’t see the Empire State from the Empire State, and the metal fence on the 86th floor can get in the way of some photos.
From Top of the Rock, you get the Empire State Building, Central Park, both rivers, the Flatiron and the Chrysler. The 70th floor is open-air, with glass barriers that don’t get in the way of your lens, and the glass-roofed elevator reaches the 67th floor in under a minute.
New York’s observation decks at a glance
| Observation deck | Deck height (approx.) | Outdoors | What you get |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empire State Building | 320 m / 1,050 ft (86th), 381 m / 1,250 ft (102nd) | Yes on the 86th, glassed-in 102nd | The Art Deco icon, downtown Manhattan, the night |
| Top of the Rock | 259 m / 850 ft (70th) | Yes, open-air 70th | The Empire State in your frame, Central Park |
| SUMMIT One Vanderbilt | 91st to 93rd floor | Mostly indoors | Architecture, mirrors, glass elevator |
| Edge (Hudson Yards) | 100th floor, over 330 m / 1,080 ft | Yes, cantilevered sky deck | Glass floor, vertigo |
| One World Observatory | Floors 100 to 102 | No, fully enclosed | The south and west of Manhattan |
Heights vary by a few meters depending on the source [Earth Trekkers], hence the « approximately ». The Empire State’s 102nd floor is glassed in, so less open than the 86th: several guides think the 86th is enough for the vast majority of visitors.
Which view for your profile
| Your profile | My pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| First time in New York | Top of the Rock | The Empire State is in the photo |
| The icon above all | Empire State Building | Open-air 86th-floor deck, 102nd as an option |
| Night out as a couple | Empire State then night cruise | City lit up, seen from above then from the water |
| Special occasion | VIP Rockefeller pass | Skip-the-line, rooftop garden, champagne |
| No queues, no crowds | SUMMIT premium | Skip-the-line at every step |
| Craving vertigo | Hudson Yards with Edge | Glass floor on the 100th floor |
Dusk, the heart of the comparison
In New York, the sun sets around 5:45 to 6:30 pm in October, and around 4:00 to 4:45 pm in November [Decks NYC, The Better Vacation]. Arrive 30 to 45 minutes earlier for security and the ascent: dusk slots go first, and it is also the busiest time at both sites. Stay until nightfall to watch the city light up. The Empire State’s official site offers a day-and-night ticket from USD 67 [esbnyc.com], a context benchmark and not a price from my cards.
The 10 best ways to see New York from above
1. Empire State Building ticket: the 86th floor and its open-air deck
This is the ticket to take if the icon matters more than the framing. The 86th-floor deck, at about 320 m, is open to the outdoors; the 102nd floor, at about 381 m, can be added as an option but it is glassed in, so I keep it for those who have already done everything else. The 4.46 rating is decent without being outstanding, and that is what pushed me to add higher-rated options further down.
- Outdoor terrace at 320 m (86th floor)
- 102nd-floor option at 381 m
- Mobile ticket, instant confirmation
2. Top of the Rock ticket: three levels and the Empire State in the frame
My choice for a first visit: this is where the Empire State Building enters the photo, with Central Park on the other side. The 70th floor, at about 259 m, is open-air, and levels 67 and 69 serve as shelter when it’s windy. At 4.28, it is the lowest rating in my selection: I say so frankly, and I’ll let you look at The Beam and SKYLIFT options when you book.
- Skyline with the Empire State Building in the frame
- 70th-floor terrace at 259 m
- The Beam and SKYLIFT options at booking
3. SUMMIT One Vanderbilt: the premium skip-the-line visit
SUMMIT bets on architecture and installations more than on the terrace: it is mainly an indoor deck, with limited outdoor space. This option is a 90-minute guided visit that skips the line at the entrance, at security and at the elevators. The price is high for an observation deck, so I’d keep it for a second visit to New York or for those who hate waiting. Access is through the Grand Central Terminal lobby.
- 90-minute guided visit
- Skip-the-line at entrance, security and elevators
- Digital photos included
4. 9/11 All-Access: Ground Zero, museum and One World Observatory
For the view over downtown Manhattan, One World Observatory is fully enclosed and air-conditioned: less open than the 86th- or 70th-floor decks, but very sharp over the Financial District. This option builds it into a half-day with a local guide at Ground Zero and the 9/11 Museum with skip-the-line entry. It is the best combination of rating and volume in my selection (4.87 across more than 5,000 reviews), a more solemn choice than a festive one. Meet at the Oculus; the guide wears an orange hat.
- One World Observatory ticket included
- Skip-the-line 9/11 Museum ticket
- Local guide, small group
5. Private Hudson Yards tour, with optional Edge access
Edge is the vertigo sky deck: a cantilevered outdoor deck on the 100th floor, with a glass floor, but without the Empire State in full frame. Here, it comes as an option on a private tour of Hudson Yards, with the Vessel and the High Line. The price shown is the price of the tour: Edge access is chosen separately, so check it when you book.
- The Vessel and the High Line
- Optional access to the Edge observation deck
- Private tour with a local guide
6. VIP Rockefeller Center pass: skip-the-line, rooftop garden and champagne
This is the « special occasion » version of Top of the Rock: a guided visit to the top, a hidden rooftop garden, a champagne toast in the Weather Room (21 and over only) and priority access at the entrance and the elevator. The price is high, and it is mostly justified if you are celebrating something. For a simple view, the standard ticket is enough.
- Guided visit of Top of the Rock
- Hidden rooftop garden
- Priority access at the entrance and elevator
7. Helicopter flight over Manhattan, 12 to 15 minutes
This is a view that no observation deck gives you, at the price of a short shared flight, with floor-to-ceiling windows. Helicopter noise is heavily criticized in the city: the city council passed a law that will ban noisy tourist flights from Manhattan heliports from December 2029, and in October 2026 flights still operate from the Downtown Manhattan Heliport. Check-in is 30 minutes before the flight.
- Shared flight of 12 to 15 minutes
- Floor-to-ceiling windows
- Heliport fees and fuel surcharge included
8. Sunset yacht cruise, 90 minutes
Observation decks show you the city from above, the cruise shows you all of it, from the water, as the light falls. I see it as the companion to a Top of the Rock visit made by day. Departure is from Chelsea Piers, Pier 62, and a drink is included.
- 90 minutes around Manhattan
- One drink included
- Skyline seen from the water
9. Night skyline cruise, 75 minutes
If you go up the Empire State by day, this would be my evening outing: the illuminated skyline seen from the river, from the same Chelsea Piers dock as the sunset cruise. The fare varies by date, hence the range, and only 21 days out of 30 are open over the checked period.
- Illuminated skyline
- One drink included
- Instant confirmation
10. New York in one day: 6-hour guided tour
I recommend it if you haven’t yet decided where to go up: a day to get a feel for the neighborhoods, see the Empire State and Rockefeller Center from the street, and work out which side speaks to you. The tour includes the Staten Island Ferry. Departure is on 7th Avenue, between 50th and 51st Streets, with 20 to 25 minutes to spare.
- Expert local guide
- Staten Island Ferry included
- Departure in the heart of Midtown
Getting ready for your trip
Get connected the moment you land in New York, handy for pulling up your ticket on your phone.
Get my eSIMWorldwide cover, useful if a flight or an excursion gets disrupted.
See the priceCompare flights to New York before locking in your observation deck tickets.
See flightsPractical tips on the ground
Pick your day based on the weather: a clear sky is essential, and the provider’s text for the Empire State states there is no refund tied to weather or waiting. For Top of the Rock, the listing says nothing about weather, so I won’t claim anything. A timed ticket bought in advance saves 45 to 60 minutes of queuing, according to The Better Vacation.
Hours shift with the season: the Empire State shows 10 am to 10 pm on its official site, other sources give 9 am to 10 pm, so check the hours for your day. Top of the Rock is open from 9 am to midnight, last entry at 11 pm. The quietest time is the morning opening. The Empire State is entered through the visitor center at 20 West 34th Street, Top of the Rock via West 50th Street, between 5th and 6th Avenue.
A French-language guide recommends the Empire State in winter, for the heaters on the 86th-floor deck, and Top of the Rock in summer, for the breeze on the open decks. That is a blog opinion, not official data, and Top of the Rock also mentions heating elements. Fall remains the clearest season, with drier air and moderate crowds.
To extend your stay, have a look at my ideas for food and design in SoHo, the Severance filming locations, and my guide to the best New Year 2027 spots, which includes New York.
Frequently asked questions
Empire State Building or Top of the Rock for a first visit?
I choose Top of the Rock: the Empire State Building is in the frame and the Central Park view is the best in Midtown. If you mostly want the icon, take the Empire State. See Top of the Rock.
Which one is taller?
The Empire State Building: the 86th-floor deck is at about 320 m (1,050 ft), the 102nd floor at about 381 m (1,250 ft). Top of the Rock stops at the 70th floor, at about 259 m (850 ft). Details on the Empire State.
What time should you go up for sunset?
The sun sets around 5:45 to 6:30 pm in October and around 4:00 to 4:45 pm in November. Arrive 30 to 45 minutes earlier and stay until nightfall.
Do you need to book in advance?
Yes, especially for dusk, because those slots go first. Over the checked period, 6 October to 4 November 2026, the Empire State and Top of the Rock tickets show 30 days open out of 30. The Empire State one has instant confirmation, the Top of the Rock one does not. See the Empire State.
Is the Empire State’s 102nd floor worth the extra cost?
Not for everyone. It is glassed in, so less open than the outdoor deck on the 86th floor, which is enough for the vast majority of visitors. I’d keep it for those who have already done everything else.
Sources
- The Better Vacation, Empire State or Top of the Rock: accessed 2026-10-05
- Our Escape Clause, Empire State or Top of the Rock: accessed 2026-10-05
- Where Are Those Morgans, comparison: accessed 2026-10-05
- Mousin Around, comparison of five observation decks: accessed 2026-10-05
- Earth Trekkers, New York observation decks: accessed 2026-10-05
- Decks NYC, best time to visit the Empire State: accessed 2026-10-05
- Empire State Building official site, tickets: accessed 2026-10-05
- SUMMIT One Vanderbilt official site: accessed 2026-10-05
- Edge official site, tickets: accessed 2026-10-05
- One World Observatory official site: accessed 2026-10-05
- Vertical Mag, New York heliport restrictions: accessed 2026-10-05
- Crain’s New York, helicopter flight limits: accessed 2026-10-05
Plan your trip with Pixidia
Pixidia learns how you travel and helps you build a trip that truly fits you and everyone coming along.
Open the planner